A literature review is not a list of summaries. It is an argument about what is already known on a topic, how securely it is known, and where the gaps lie. You may write one as a chapter of a dissertation, as a standalone assignment, or as part of a research proposal. In each case your reader wants to see that you understand the field and can use it to justify your own work.

This checklist takes you through the process in stages, with a short explanation of each. It is designed for the narrative literature reviews most students write. Systematic reviews follow formal published methods, often with registered protocols, and if you are asked to write one, your department's guidance and those methods take priority.

The checklist at a glance

Use this summary to see where you are. Each stage is explained in detail below.

  1. Define your scope: state your topic or question in one or two sentences and decide what is in and out.
  2. Search systematically: use your library search and the main databases for your subject, and keep a record of your searches.
  3. Screen and select: remove irrelevant sources by title and abstract, then judge the quality of the rest.
  4. Read and record: take notes in the same structure for every source: aim, method, findings, limitations and relevance.
  5. Synthesise, do not summarise: group sources by the questions they address and explain where they agree and conflict.
  6. Choose a structure: thematic, chronological or methodological, whichever suits your question.
  7. Write critically: match your language to the strength of the evidence and make your own voice visible.
  8. Final checks: clear paragraph points, complete and consistent referencing, scope, word limit and proofreading.

What a literature review is for

A good review does several things at once. It sets out the context of your topic, shows what researchers agree and disagree about, evaluates the quality of the evidence, identifies what has not yet been studied or resolved, and explains how your own question responds to that situation.

Stage 1: Define your scope

  • I can state my topic or research question in one or two sentences.
  • I have decided which time period, places, populations or disciplines are included, and I can explain why.
  • I know the expected length and format from my assignment brief or handbook.
  • I know whether my department expects a narrative review or a more structured approach.

A clear scope saves time. Without one, every source looks relevant and the review never ends.

Stage 2: Search systematically

Start with your university library's search tool and the main databases for your subject, such as PubMed for health and life sciences, ERIC for education, or multidisciplinary databases such as Scopus and Web of Science where your library provides access. Google Scholar is useful for finding material quickly, but it is harder to search precisely and it mixes peer reviewed work with other material, so check what you find.

Build your searches deliberately:

  • List your key concepts, then several synonyms for each. A search for "remote work" might also need "telework" and "working from home".
  • Combine terms with Boolean operators. OR widens a search (telework OR "remote work"); AND narrows it ("remote work" AND wellbeing); NOT excludes a term.
  • Use quotation marks to search for an exact phrase.
  • Use truncation where the database supports it. In many databases, educat* finds education, educational and educator.
  • Use the filters for date range, language and document type.
  • Record each search: the database, the terms, the date and the number of results. This makes your search repeatable and helps you describe it in your methodology if needed.

Our Research Finder can also help you search several open academic databases.

Checklist:

  • I have searched more than one database.
  • I have tried synonyms and related terms for each concept.
  • I have recorded my searches.
  • I have followed useful references backwards through reference lists, and forwards by checking who has cited key articles since.

Stage 3: Screen and select

  • I have read titles and abstracts to remove sources that are clearly irrelevant.
  • I have judged the quality of the remaining sources, considering how they were produced, their methods, their date and their relevance.
  • I have kept older, foundational works where the field still relies on them.
  • I can explain why I left out sources that might seem relevant.

Peer review is a useful sign of quality, but it does not guarantee that a study is strong or that its conclusions apply to your question. Judge each source on its merits.

Stage 4: Read and record

Use a consistent note structure for every source: the full reference, the aim, the method, the main findings, the limitations, and how the source relates to your question. A literature matrix, with one row per source and one column per heading, makes patterns visible quickly. You can download our free literature review matrix template, and our guide to reading journal articles efficiently explains how to extract this information without reading every article from start to finish.

  • I have notes on every source I plan to cite.
  • My notes separate the authors' findings from their interpretations.
  • Every quotation in my notes has quotation marks and a page number.

Stage 5: Synthesise, do not summarise

Synthesis is the difference between a weak review and a strong one. Instead of describing one source after another, you group sources by the questions they address and explain how they relate: where they agree, where they conflict, and why.

Hypothetical example: the three studies below are imaginary and are described only to show the difference between summary and synthesis. They are not evidence from real research. In your own review, every statement about a study would carry a citation in your referencing style.

Summary: The first study surveyed students at one university and found that shorter sleep was associated with lower exam marks. The second study also examined sleep and reported a similar result. The third study interviewed students about their sleep habits.

Synthesis: Both surveys report an association between shorter sleep and lower assessment performance. However, both rely on self reported sleep collected at a single institution, which limits how far the findings can be generalised and leaves open whether poor sleep lowers marks or whether exam stress affects both. The interview study suggests that students link late nights to workload rather than leisure, a possible explanation the surveys did not measure.

The second version makes a point, connects the sources, evaluates them, and leads towards a question that still needs answering.

  • My paragraphs are organised around ideas or themes, not individual sources.
  • I compare and evaluate sources rather than describing them one by one.
  • I explain the reasons for disagreements where I can.

Stage 6: Choose a structure

Common structures include:

  • Thematic: sections built around the main themes or debates. This suits most student reviews.
  • Chronological: tracing how thinking developed over time. This works when the history of the debate matters.
  • Methodological: grouping studies by research approach, which is useful when methods shape the findings.
  • Theoretical: organising the review around competing theories or frameworks.

Whatever structure you choose, include a short introduction explaining the scope and organisation of the review, and a conclusion that draws the threads together.

Stage 7: Write critically and precisely

  • I use cautious, accurate language that matches the strength of the evidence, such as "suggests", "indicates" or "is associated with", rather than "proves".
  • My own voice is visible: I explain what the evidence means, not only what it says.
  • I describe gaps honestly. I write "few studies have examined" only when my searching supports it, and I avoid claiming that no research exists unless I am confident.
  • My conclusion explains how the gap I have identified leads to my research question.

Our critical thinking guide has more advice on evaluating evidence.

Stage 8: Final checks

  • Every paragraph opens with a clear point.
  • Every claim drawn from a source is referenced.
  • Citations and reference list entries match, in a consistent style. See our Harvard and APA guides.
  • The review stays within its stated scope and word limit.
  • I have proofread the review separately from writing it.

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

  • Writing an annotated list. Group sources by theme and compare them.
  • Including everything you read. Select what serves your argument.
  • Relying only on very recent work, or only on old work. Balance foundational sources with current research.
  • Ignoring evidence that contradicts your view. Engaging with it strengthens your review.
  • Stopping without a conclusion. End by stating what is known, what is not, and why your question matters.

Frequently asked questions

How many sources should a literature review include?

There is no fixed number. It depends on the level of study, the topic and the length of the review. Your handbook or supervisor is the best guide.

Can I include books, reports and websites?

Yes, where they are credible and relevant. Academic books and reports from reputable organisations are often valuable. Be more cautious with websites, and check who produced them and why.

How recent should my sources be?

It depends on the field. Fast moving areas need current research, but foundational older works are still appropriate when the field relies on them.

Related article on our blog: How to Structure a Literature Review and How to Build a Literature Review Matrix.

References

None. This article gives general guidance and does not cite specific sources.

Further reading

Hart, C. (2018) Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Research Imagination. 2nd edn. SAGE.

Wallace, M. and Wray, A. (2016) Critical Reading and Writing for Postgraduates. 3rd edn. SAGE.

Back to all resources