Research notes, sticky notes and a tablet on a study desk

Once you have collected more than a handful of sources, keeping track of what each one says becomes difficult. A literature review matrix solves this. It is a simple table that records the same information about every source, side by side, so you can compare studies, spot patterns and find gaps at a glance. It is also the most reliable bridge between reading your sources and writing a review that synthesises them.

This article explains what a literature review matrix is, which columns to include, how to build one step by step, and how to turn it into well organised writing.

What is a literature review matrix?

A literature review matrix, sometimes called a synthesis matrix, is a grid with one row for each source and one column for each type of information you want to compare. Instead of separate notes on separate pages, everything sits in one place. When you read down a column, you see how all your sources handle the same question, which is exactly what synthesis requires.

Which columns to include

Choose columns that match your research question. A good starting set is:

  • Reference: author, year and a short title, so you can find the source again.
  • Aim or question: what the study set out to find.
  • Method: for example survey, interviews, experiment or review.
  • Sample and context: who or what was studied, where and when.
  • Key findings: the main results in your own words.
  • Strengths and limitations: your evaluation of the evidence.
  • Themes: short labels for the topics the source contributes to.
  • Relevance: how the source relates to your own question.

Keep the number of columns manageable. Eight focused columns are more useful than twenty you never fill in.

A sample matrix

Hypothetical example: the studies below are invented for this article to show how a matrix is filled in. They are not real research.

SourceMethodSampleKey findingsLimitationsThemes
Study A (Year)SurveyUndergraduates at one universityOnline quizzes linked to higher reported engagementSelf reported data; one institutionEngagement, assessment
Study B (Year)InterviewsTwenty lecturers in two countriesLecturers valued quizzes but reported extra workloadSmall sample; staff view onlyWorkload, assessment
Study C (Year)ExperimentTwo first year classesQuiz group scored higher on the final testShort time frameAttainment, assessment

Reading down the Themes column shows that all three studies address assessment, while only one looks at workload: a possible gap. Reading the Limitations column shows that the evidence comes from small or single institution samples, which is an important point for your evaluation.

How to build your matrix, step by step

  1. Start from your question. Write your research question above the table and choose columns that help answer it.
  2. Set up the table. A spreadsheet works well because you can sort and filter rows. A table in a word processor is fine for smaller reviews.
  3. Add sources as you read. Fill in a row as soon as you finish each source, while it is fresh. Our guide on how to read a journal article in 15 minutes shows how to find the key details quickly.
  4. Write in your own words. Short paraphrased notes protect you from accidental plagiarism later. If you copy a phrase, put it in quotation marks with the page number.
  5. Label themes consistently. Use the same few theme labels across rows, and refine them as patterns appear.
  6. Review the columns, not just the rows. Regularly read down each column to see agreements, disagreements and missing areas.

From matrix to writing

The matrix becomes your writing plan. Sort or filter the rows by theme, and each theme becomes a section of your review. Within each section, write paragraphs that make a point and bring several sources together: where they agree, where they differ, and why. Differences in method or sample, which you have already recorded, often explain why studies disagree.

For the overall shape of the review, see our article on how to structure a literature review, and use our literature review checklist before you submit.

Common mistakes

  • Copying abstracts into the table. Summarise in your own words instead, so the matrix reflects your understanding.
  • Leaving the evaluation column empty. Your judgement of each source is what turns description into critical analysis.
  • Inconsistent theme labels. Five different names for the same idea hide the patterns you are looking for.
  • Building the matrix after writing. It is most useful while you read, not as a record afterwards.

Frequently asked questions

Is a literature review matrix the same as an annotated bibliography?

No. An annotated bibliography describes each source separately. A matrix puts sources side by side under the same headings, which makes comparison and synthesis much easier.

Should I use a spreadsheet or a table in a document?

Either works. Spreadsheets are better for larger reviews because you can sort and filter by theme, method or year.

How many sources should go into the matrix?

Every source you are likely to discuss in your review. Sources you decide not to use can be moved to a separate sheet so they do not clutter your analysis.

Related resources: how to structure a literature review, literature review checklist, and how to read a journal article.

References

None. This article gives general guidance and does not cite specific sources.

Further reading

Hart, C. (2018) Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Research Imagination. 2nd edn. SAGE.

Booth, W.C., Colomb, G.G., Williams, J.M., Bizup, J. and FitzGerald, W.T. (2024) The Craft of Research. 5th edn. University of Chicago Press.

Back to all articles